A question raised by Christine Fréchette that deserves reflection

During a recent meeting with the agricultural sector attended by our Premier of Québec, Christine Fréchette, a question was raised:

Should food processors fall more under the Ministry of Economy rather than the Ministry of Agriculture in our respective provinces?

Food processing holds a special position in our economy. In Québec, the food processing sector is deeply connected to Québec agriculture, as it purchases more than 70% of all Québec agricultural products. It is closely linked to agricultural production, but it also constitutes a manufacturing sector that must invest, automate, integrate new technologies, increase its productivity, develop its markets, and remain competitive both here and internationally.

This raises a broader question: are our ways of supporting our industry still adapted to the reality of today’s businesses? Or, could better alignment with economic and industrial levers accelerate the adoption of technologies and the growth of our businesses, while preserving the essential link with the agricultural sector?

The question was posed by the CTAQ, and now it is my turn to want to know your opinion regarding your provincial government:

How could we, collectively, evolve policies and government levers to better meet the future needs of food processing and its innovation ecosystem?

Hello Julie,

These are excellent questions to which I unfortunately cannot respond since I am not part of those ministries 😊

Keep us informed of your thoughts and actions.

Looking forward to hearing from you,

Hello Julie,

There are certainly similarities between the needs of food processing companies and other manufacturing businesses, as you clearly indicate in your message (automation, integration of new technologies, increased productivity, market development, etc.). Food processing companies are already eligible for programs and assistance from the MEIE and IQ without specifically “falling under” them. Perhaps these organisations are not well known to entrepreneurs in the sector, who tend to turn instead to the MAPAQ and do not look at what the MEIE and IQ (Départ, MSN, etc.) offer them?

The regulatory component constitutes the main difference with the rest of the manufacturing industry, and it currently falls under the MAPAQ, with some similarities to the agricultural sector. I struggle to see what advantage there would be in transferring this aspect to the MEIE.

The Fisheries sector, which forms a separate sector within the MAPAQ, must not be forgotten. This sector includes a processing component. It already has its own programs and support distinct from the rest of food processing at the MAPAQ. Due to its particularities, within the food processing sector and within MAPAQ, I find it difficult to see this sector falling under the MEIE.

At the level of the innovation ecosystem, of which the organisation I work with is a part, companies in the food processing sector are eligible for most of the MEIE programs aimed at the manufacturing industry. It is at the level of sectoral assistance that, in my opinion, this sector is a “poor relation”. Other sectors receive much more support, notably because they have been identified as priorities of the Government of Québec (metal processing, AI, critical materials, etc.).

1 Like

Thank you for such a nuanced response, Pierre; I think you have hit the nail on the head.

I agree that the regulatory aspect must remain with MAPAQ, just as the fisheries sector does. That is not where the real issue lies.

Your point about entrepreneurs in the sector being unaware of MEIE and IQ programmes seems valid to me, and it may be a concrete and quick action path: better promoting what already exists, rather than reinventing the wheel.

But it is your last point that resonates most with me: the fact that food processing remains the "poor relation" in terms of sectoral support. If sectors like metal fabrication, AI, or critical materials have been identified as government priorities, what tipped the balance in those cases? I would be curious to know whether that was supported by precise economic impact data or more by sustained sector mobilisation.

Because with more than 70% of Quebec’s agricultural purchases passing through processing, we have a solid economic case to make. Perhaps this is where organisations such as CFIN-RCIA and the CTAQ have a role to play: documenting this economic weight and pushing for food processing to be recognised as a strategic sector in its own right, not just eligible for existing programmes but actively prioritised.

Could this be organised, for example, in the form of a working group bringing together MAPAQ, MEIE, IQ, and processors? Thank you!

a { text-decoration: none; color: #464feb; } tr th, tr td { border: 1px solid #e6e6e6; } tr th { background-color: #f5f5f5; }

I find this question very relevant because it highlights an important reality: Canadian food processors are situated at the crossroads of several ministries, both at the provincial and federal levels, notably those of Agriculture, Health, Industry, and Innovation.

This reality demonstrates the strategic importance of the agri-food sector for our economy. However, it also presents a challenge: when a sector falls under multiple authorities, there is sometimes a risk that it may not be fully prioritized by any of them. Agriculture ministries naturally have as their main mandate the support of agricultural production, while the ministries responsible for economic and industrial development often focus their efforts on more traditional manufacturing sectors, such as aerospace, automotive, or metallurgy.

Yet, food processing is primarily a manufacturing activity. It must invest in automation, adopt new technologies, increase its productivity, and remain competitive in national and international markets. However, despite its status as the largest employer in the manufacturing sector in several jurisdictions, it is not always fully part of the industrial portfolio.

In my opinion, the question may not be whether food processing should fall exclusively under Agriculture or Economy, but rather how we can better align policies, programs, and government levers to fully acknowledge its dual identity: that of an essential partner to the agricultural sector and that of a major manufacturing driver.

What could be possible to accomplish if the main industrial development levers were further mobilized for the benefit of the country’s largest manufacturing employer? This is certainly a reflection worth exploring further.

1 Like

Thank you for this reflection, Robert!

You highlight a fundamental issue: food processing is at the crossroads of several government priorities, but this cross-functionality should not become an obstacle to its development.

I particularly share your point of view on the need to move beyond the “Agriculture or Economy” debate. In my opinion, the main question is: do we currently have the right levers, in the right place, to enable food processing to innovate, invest, and increase productivity?

And this is where innovation becomes essential.

Automation, robotics, artificial intelligence, new processes, biotechnologies, energy efficiency: technologies are evolving rapidly, but their adoption at an industrial scale requires significant investments, support, and programmes that take into account the unique reality of processors.

And perhaps the real question is this: how can we make innovation and food processing a full economic priority while maintaining the strategic link with agriculture?

I believe there is considerable potential here for our companies, regions, and economy. The question certainly deserves to be explored collectively.